Timothy Noah was a senior writer at Slate, a Washington reporter for the
Wall Street Journal, and author of The Great Divergence: America's Growing
Inequality Crisis and What We Can Do About It (Bloomsbury).
... The distribution of income in the United States is skewed toward the
rich, but the distribution of wealth is skewed much more heavily toward the
rich. Why didn’t I write a book about that? ... Whereas median family income
fell about 8 percent during that period, which covers the 2007-2009
recession and the first year of the present (weak) recovery, median net
worth fell about 39 percent.
...
If you own a house what you've really got (until you pay off your mortgage)
is debt. About half of all households own stock (usually through mutual
funds) but only about one-sixth possess stock holdings worth $7,000 or more.
Eighty-one percent of all stocks are owned by by the top 10 percent.
Overall, the top 10 percent possesses about three-quarters of all the wealth
in the U.S. (By comparison, it possesses about 45 percent of the income.)
So wealth is pretty much a non-issue for most people.
...
But the U.S. government has never really been in the business of
redistributing wealth in any direct way. Wealth is typically not taxed. Income is
taxed. Taking away a person's wealth is expropriation. Taking away a
person's income—some of it, anyway—is merely asking that person to pay his
or her fair share to support the operations of government.
2-4-8 Letter to the Editor Response
Tax Wealth and Income for Sustainable
Economic Growth
In "Income, Not Wealth" Timothy Noah wrongly contends
the, “U.S. government has never been in the business of redistributing
wealth in any direct way" and proclaims that taxing, "a person's wealth is
expropriation". The tax code - (tax expenditures a/k/a “loopholesâ€) has
redistributed income and wealth from the middle class to the top at a rate
in excess of $1 trillion for over 20 years. Mr. Noah has to realize that
people are taxed and income, net wealth and consumption are simply the
measure of how much the tax should be.
A powerful and resilient tax blend can heal the economy
by adding a VAT ($10 trillion sales base) and net wealth ($53 trillion
individual base) to the income ($13 trillion individual and corporate base).
For Business: 8% corporate rate and 4% VAT - (“tax
perfection†with no downside) For Individuals: 8% individual rate and 2%
net wealth – (excluding $15,000 savings and all retirement funds) A
typical family would save or spend $640 more per month, business would add
jobs to meet the increased demand and owners would reap handsome profit.
This 2-4-8 Tax Blend is the only tax reform that creates sustainable
economic growth with no government subsidy.
Eugene Patrick Devany, JD, MPA
www.TaxNetWealth.com
Massapequa Park, NY
|